From the Request for Destruction of Materials to Complete Dismissal

The Course of Action in a Trademark Misuse Lawsuit

Imagine that an agricultural machinery manufacturer is faced with a lawsuit filed by a competitor alleging misuse of a term in its product line, accusing it of unfair competition and trademark imitation. The plaintiff seeks the immediate cessation of sales, the destruction of advertising materials, and the payment of damages.

What many people think: “If the competitor was the first to use that term in the market and sued us, we will be forced to change the name and pay damages.”

In practice, this is not the case.

Specialized legal expertise makes it possible to assess the actual strength of the term within the relevant market, demonstrating before the Court that descriptive terms cannot be monopolized by a single company.

In certain cases, it is possible to dismiss the accusation and obtain total dismissal of the action by demonstrating, for example:

  • That the term in question is generic or evocative (as a term in English that only describes the function of the equipment);
  • The lack of sufficient distinctiveness to warrant exclusive rights in a trademark;
  • That the relevant public in the sector is highly specialized, ruling out any concrete risk of confusion;
  • Peaceful coexistence in the market due to significant visual differences in the overall appearance of the marks.

With proper reasoning, the rights of the company are safeguarded. As an example, in a recent case, the technical defense guaranteed the complete victory of the defendant.

  • The conflict: A company sued a livestock machinery manufacturer, alleging the misuse of an English term used to name its product and seeking an injunction against the use of the mark, the destruction of promotional materials, and financial compensation for unfair competition.
  • The defense strategy: In the response to the complaint, the defense demonstrated that the term used means “feeder” and merely describes the product’s function. As it is a generic term, it does not have the necessary distinctiveness to guarantee exclusive use in the market.
  • Analysis of the public: It was also evident that the graphic differences between the products were striking and that buyers in the sector are technical consumers, fully capable of differentiating the brands without any confusion.

The decision: The judge fully accepted the defense thesis and dismissed the action AS TOTALLY UNFOUNDED, stating that the courts require sufficient distinctiveness and a concrete risk of confusion to prohibit the use of a name. The Court recognized the peaceful coexistence of the marks in the market, and the plaintiff accepted the decision without filing an appeal.